PeerPoint Ad 

 

You are here: Home Resources Medical Review Blog Discredited Research Study Stuns a Colleague
Document Actions

Discredited Research Study Stuns a Colleague

An ex-Army doctor finds his name on a study that he didn't conduct.

So this story is pretty scary, even though it seems harmless at first.

Everyone likes receiving accolades for their hard work, whether it is in something as simple as the weekend softball game or after a huge business presentation or giant discovery. It's tough, and down right awkward and confusing, to receive accolades for something that you have no idea about.

Enter Dr. Romney C. Andersen, a Walter Reed Army Medical Center surgeon. Last summer, Dr. Andersen was congratulated on a very successful study that he conducted. Or supposedly conducted.

What really occurred was the theft of Dr. Andersen's name by a discredited researcher and surgeon , Dr. Timothy Kuklo, who conducted an unapproved study but used Dr. Andersen's name in order to get it published.

According to the article in the New York Times, episodes like the one involving Dr. Kuklo, show "how medical journals may fail to conduct adequate due diligence on the studies they publish -- information that other doctors rely on for guidance."

Again, this is a pretty scary story with fairly severe consequences. If physicians and hospitals cannot trust studies, what are patients supposed to trust? Physicians, surgeons, doctors and nurses all rely heavily upon the outcomes of research and studies because those outcomes create the basis of evidence-based medicine which further establish best practices. If our best practices are based off of faulty or inadequate research, what hope for trust does that give our patients?

To read the full article, click here:

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/06/06/business/06surgeon.html?_r=1&ref=health

Rating
Average Rating:
3.0 (381 Votes )
Rated objects
Recent Comments
Weblog Authors

Amie Dahnke

Amie Dahnke

Andrew Rowe

Andrew Rowe

Sean Wolverton

Location: Portland, OR
Sean Wolverton
I've been AllMed's Marketing Communications Specialist since May of 2007. My main duties are the updating and moderating the website, and creating the monthly newsletters called PeerPoints. Outside of work I enjoy playing golf on the weekends, snowboarding, and exploring Portland.